Hosted by Aaron Garth. Free to listen on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
After a critical incident, youth workers need more than an incident report. They need a proper debrief. In this episode Aaron explains two models Ultimate Youth Worker uses, the After Action Review and the Critical Incident Stress Debrief, and how individuals and teams can use them.
Youth workers are with young people at their best and at their darkest. In their darkest moments, young people may lash out, run away or harm themselves, and youth workers find themselves managing a critical incident: keeping people safe, giving first aid and calling emergency services when needed. Afterwards, too often, all that’s left is an incident report and perhaps a referral to an employee assistance program that doesn’t understand youth work.
Aaron explains two models that sit within a wider Critical Incident Stress Management framework.
The After Action Review is a team process for learning from what happened. Done openly and without blame, it looks at four things: what was intended, what actually happened, why it happened, and what was learnt. One person facilitates and records the results.
The Critical Incident Stress Debrief is narrower. Often described as psychological first aid, it usually takes place within 48 hours of a traumatic event. It assesses the impact on staff, deals with immediate safety concerns, makes space for people to talk through their thoughts and reactions, prepares them for what may come, and connects them to further support. It isn’t counselling.
You’re listening to the Ultimate Youth Worker Podcast, today’s episode. Debriefing after an incident. Let’s get into this. You’re listening to the Ultimate UseWorker Podcast with your host, Aaron Garth! Welcome back to another episode of the Ultimate Youth Worker podcast. You’re here with Aaron and I just want to say thanks again. We know that at the moment things are a bit crazy in the world and it’s easy to skip out on listening to a podcast like this. And we just wanted to thank you for joining us again. Hey, if you haven’t already done it. Can you subscribe to whatever podcast catcher you’re using? Hit that subscribe button so that you get every notification for the podcasts as they come out.
Now you might have noticed that we didn’t post a podcast last week or the week before that. And we were taking a bit of a break. We had been chatting with a few different groups that we’ve been involved with. A couple of groups, things like the Racial Justice Collective, which is a group that I highly recommend that you get involved with, around the Black Lives Matter issue that has come up in the States. And as an organization, we started to have a bit of a conversation around what that means for us here in Australia. It’s easy for us to see things on the web or on television in other countries and think, oh, that’s a huge issue over there.
Is over there, it’s away from us and we can kind of puff ourselves up and say how bad that is and that people need to do something about it but we can forget that in our own in our own backyard that things are not as as rosy as we would think that they are. Here in Australia there have been a number of deaths of Aboriginal people in custody. In fact since the 1991 Royal Commission into this 434 Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander people have died in custody. Now there’s some out there who will say that those numbers are inflated or they don’t meet the statistics or you know a number of different things.
In fact some of the key media commentators in Australia tried to poo-poo these numbers and say that that wasn’t the case. But the research is pretty clear out there. Aboriginal people have died in custody. Now, they’re correct in saying that those numbers are not disproportionate. Those numbers are pretty similar for white people, etc. However, what they don’t say is that Aboriginal people are more likely to be incarcerated. In fact, a key finding of the Royal Commission in 1991 was that Aboriginal people are more likely to die in custody because they’re arrested and jailed at disproportionate rates. In 1991, that rate was 14.3% of the male prison population in Australia.
In March 2020, it’s 28.6% of the population. We arrest and jail Indigenous people more readily than we do other groups. And that is why these numbers. Are so disproportionate and why we in Australia need to be aware of that. Now that’s just one issue in a myriad of issues when it comes to race. And issues of hour in Australia. We could talk about. The levels of education of our indigenous people, we could talk about the gaps in healthcare. There are so many issues out there. And as a staff team at Ultimate Youth Worker, we wanted to start thinking about some of those things and. And really mulling it over, not just giving it a bit of lip service.
We started to discuss with some of the organizations that were involved in how we can understand more of this. And one of the big things that as youth workers we need to do is have an understanding of the history of race relations in Australia, the history of how indigenous people have been treated and the Real pain and suffering. That colonialization has caused in this country. We also started to unpack our own understandings of culture and our own lives. And we just want to give a shout out to the. Through at Mahana Culture for helping us to start thinking that through. Mahana has done amazing work in the area of cultural intelligence over the years.
And particularly we just want to give them a shout out. And you’ll hear a bit more about Mahana in a few casts time. But for us, it was a time of thinking and reading and learning and really starting to come to grips with how we as youth workers in Australia. And how we as a company can our Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander brothers and sisters. How we can to get alongside them and to give them the respect that they deserve and to be allies and partners in their cause. We don’t have all the answers. We’re far from there, but we do. I think that it is time for.
Australia as a nation to really put this stuff on on the map to start talking about it to make it a genuine discussion and Hopefully we can play a little part in that. All of you listening out there and for our Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander listeners, we just want to extend a hand and say we’re here, we want to learn and we hope that we can journey with you in this process. Sorry With that being said, we’ve had a bit of time to look at a few other things. And one of those that came up is we’ve been doing a lot of critical incident debriefing with organizations and with people.
There’s been a few incidents that have happened in some of the areas that we work in, in residential care, drug and alcohol, etc. And a lot of those have been simply because of the COVID-19. Wall climbing that we all seem to be doing, being locked in our houses and not being able to get out and about. And this has caused a number of incidents in the groups that we work with, things like residential care, drug and alcohol, mental health. And we’ve been supporting a lot of youth workers in their organizations in how they deal with these critical incidents. And we’ve noticed that there’s no clear path for a lot of organizations and particularly the smaller organizations that we’ve worked with have really struggled in dealing with some of these critical incidents because of a lack of a.
The act critical incident stress management framework. We’re not gonna talk a lot about the Critical Incident Stress Management Framework. We’ll probably do that in another cast along the ways. But Critical Incident Debriefing or Critical Incident Stress Debriefing is just one part of a wider model of critical incident stress management. There’s a lot in the models out there on critical incident stress management. We’re not gonna touch on that, but we will talk. Specifically today about how we go about critical incident stress debriefing. Unfortunately, a lot of people, when we first deal with them, it’s because they’ve been referred to us because they’ve been involved in a critical incident, that they’ve been involved in an incident in the past.
And those things have led to some kind of issue, either they’re looking at finishing up in their role. Or they’re having some struggles with their current work because of that. And we often come in later in the process and we’ve been really lucky to have. Been supporting organisations earlier and earlier in this space. We know a lot of organizations get their team leaders or their managers to provide some level of support in this area, but if you haven’t had any training in it and look to be honest, most. Youth workers, social workers, psychologists haven’t done a lot of training around critical incident management. They’re just gonna be grasping at straws.
They’re gonna try and do what they’ve done in their own life or maybe what their managers have done in this case. They may farm you off to the employee assistance program. And once again, a lot of the people who work in employee assistance programs haven’t provided the types of work, the care that residential care workers, drug and alcohol workers in that space have done so they don’t really get. What’s happened and how it’s come about in your space. So. Often times, unfortunately, the issues that come up from critical incidents really go unresolved. And we find that that then creeps into the practice of youth workers later.
Ultimate Youth Worker, we work with a lot of organizations to implement a strong critical incident stress management framework and we train others to use two different yet important models in this. One of those is called the after action review and the other is the critical incident stress debrief. And they both have different kind of frameworks and different ideas in how this works. So let’s start with the after action review. The After Action Review is a process used by teams to recognize and understand the lessons learned from successes and failures with the goal of improving future. Performance. After some form of action has been taken, how it worked and We’ve used the After Action Review mainly with organisations around projects that have gone awry, things like camps that haven’t worked very well and incidents have popped up there.
We’ve used them where group programs haven’t worked very well and particularly where many members of a team are involved. After action reviews should be carried out with an open spirit and without any blame. The military uses the phrase “Leave your rank at the door”. There’s no one who is the leader in this, there’s no team leader, manager, nothing like that. Everyone is on the same footing. You have a person who takes on the role of the leader of the process and they facilitate the capturing of results. And really the after action review comes in the form of four things that we’re looking at. First one was what was intended?
What was the process that we expected was going to happen? How did we intend to deal with whatever the the issue the action was. Actually happened. What was it that. After all of our thoughts and processes actually happened? Was it that a young person absconded? Was it that there was some larger issue, things like suicidality, et cetera, but what? Actually happened. Then there’s a process of reflection and asking why it happened. What were the things that happened? What were the building blocks of this action that happened? And then finally, what was learned from it? We really like this model and it works particularly if you’re after something quick and easy for everyone to get involved with in and reflect.
We like using it within our team here at Ultimate Youth Worker. After running programs and that even beyond a critical incident process because it gives us an opportunity to do the reflection. And all too often when we’re talking with. Clients here at Ultimate Youth Worker and we ask about critical incidents. They tell us they filled out the form, they’ve sent it off to whoever they needed to send it off to. But there’s no time to reflect, there’s no time to think through did, What we want to happen, did the process that we’re trained to use work, was there anything that we could have learned about ourselves or the young person?
Uhh. In this time, there’s no reflection. So the After Action Review is a really great simple tool to use to help start this process. And we would recommend if you don’t have any process at the moment, this is a really good one for you to start with. 4 things, what was intended to happen, what actually happened, why it happened and what was learned from the action. It’s a really good process for peer reflection and peer support in this one too. From that process. Of the after action report. We need to build on things though. We can’t leave it there. It’s a great model. It works really well.
But when we’ve had a really large incident something like a person who’s suicided or there’s been absconding from programs or something has gone really pear shaped. The after action review is great, but we need something that’s a little bit broader. And as we set at the start You need a comprehensive critical incident stress management framework. Within that. Framework is this idea of critical incident stress debriefing. And out of the critical incident stress debriefing, we need to focus and strategically focus on the detailed disclosure of facts, thoughts, and emotional reactions linked to a particularly traumatic event. Often in the literature Critical incident stress debriefing is linked with psychological first aid.
It’s generally carried out within 48 hours of the incident. This is often where you send off to the employee assistance program and hopefully they’ll solve the issue. Now we want to. A few things. Critical incident stress debriefing, it’s not counselling, it’s not psychotherapy. That may be part of a wider critical incident stress management framework. Critical incident debriefing is a very rigorous, very clear process. Of seven steps. To help you to. Deal with the outflowing of a traumatic incident. So let’s go through what those seven steps are. The first step is to assess the impact of the critical incident on people around you or the other youth workers in our case as youth workers.
Also you may involve volunteers in this it might be the young people themselves as well. We need to do a bit of an audit of how they’ve been impacted as we know from our studies trauma affects people differently. Put five people in a traumatic event and they will each deal with it differently. Some may not have any issue with it at all and they feel quite robust and they’re able to deal with what’s going on. Others may fall to pieces. And so we need to assess where they’re at and how they have Um. Come to terms with surviving their traumatic event. From there. We need to move on to the level two, which is identifying immediate issues surrounding problems involving safety and security.
We need to make sure that the safety and security of all involved is Harrow Mount. If, as we dealt with earlier in this year here in Victoria, you’re having a bit of a debrief because there’s bushfires and bushfires have come through your town. You’re not going to just sit down and start to have a conversation with the fires still raging around you. We need to make sure that you’re safe and you feel secure. And this is the same no matter what situation you’re in. It might be that. Been working with a young person who’s highly suicidal and we need to make sure that they’re safe and secure so that we can feel safe and secure.
You might be working with a young person who’s been abused physically or sexually and you need to make sure that you feel safe. And secure in talking about those things. So as the people who were. Providing the debrief in this space. We need to make sure everyone is feeling safe and secure. And we can do that in a number of ways. We can make sure that. The environment that we’re in is safe and secure. We’re not going to do it out in the bullpen with everyone around. We’re just going to get those who were involved in the incident together in a room where we’re feeling safe.
We’re probably not gonna have bright light shining on everyone and lots of noise and all those things. We wanna make this a place where we feel safe. And secure. We’re also going to make sure that they know that this is a safe and secure place. You can talk about it. We’re not here to get anyone for doing the wrong thing. That’s not the process. Of a critical incident stress debrief. It’s a process of thinking it through and validating feelings and anchoring. We’re gonna make sure that they know they’re safe, that they can talk about what’s happened. And that they’re secure, that nothing’s gonna come from this discussion that will lead to them losing their job or anything like that.
This is a safe space. Step three is that we need to use some techniques to help people vent their thoughts, their emotions, the experiences that are associated with this event. And we need to allow time to validate those feelings. And the possible reactions that come from them. We did some debrief with organizations because of the bushfires. And there were a lot of different reactions. There were people who had left the bushfire zone who had only been up there for a little while and they’d returned to the safety of Melbourne and they were like, “Yep, we just want to get back on with the job.” It was scary, we saw some bad stuff, all that type of thing, but life is okay, we’re getting back to it.
There were other people who were like, no, my life is back in those towns. I have to go back there next week. You know, this is too much for me. I’m really struggling. So we needed to allow We needed to allow time for people to vent, allow some framed discussions around their thoughts and their emotions and the experiences that they had. And then to validate that those thoughts and feelings. Are okay, that those thoughts and feelings and the reactions of their bodies, the visceral stuff is okay. And post-traumatic events we would expect that there’s going to be different responses from different people and all of those possible reactions are okay.
For about critical incident stress debrief is to predict events and reactions that are gonna happen in the aftermath of the event. If we’ve had to deal with a young person who has died because of suicide. Then there’s going to be reactions to that. You may have nightmares, you may struggle to come back into the workplace, you may want to just scream because of it. We? In this process. With you the event and reactions to come. Bushfire example. We talked about the cleanup and the aftermath and the smell of smoke and how are you going to deal with all of those things? When we’ve worked with people where there’s been violence in the workplace, so things like residential where young people have hurt.
Staff members we talk about. Going back into the workplace, seeing that young person, conversing with them. How are you gonna deal with all of those type of events that come up? The key in this one is to be as comprehensive as we can, to talk through what may happen. This isn’t a guarantee, it may not happen. But we want to be as comprehensive and predict as many of those events as we possibly can. Knowledge is power in this one. And if you know these things are going to happen, they are less likely to. Take over. Your senses take over your your ability to code. Once we’ve done all that We come to it Part 5 and this is where we conduct a systematic review of the incident and its impacts emotionally cognitively and physically on those who have survived the trauma.
What we’re looking for here is any maladaptive behavioral responses to the crisis or trauma. As we start to unpack. The incident, what happened, when, how, why, who, etc. We as the person who is conducting this stress debrief is looking for the behavioral responses that go beyond normal, the normal range of feelings here. So we’re looking for things like withdrawal, we’re looking for things about self injury, we’re looking for uh. People who blow up and yell and rant and rave. We’re looking for those maladaptive behavioral responses because those people who are taking this incident, this traumatic incident on board to the point where it is significantly affecting their behavior are going to need further support.
That might be ongoing counseling or psychology support. Could be time off work, et cetera. So we’re looking for the people within this group that we’re debriefing with and how we can deal with those responses. Number six, step six, once we’ve had this time of systematic review, We want to bring some closure to the incident and we’re going to anchor or ground if you like the. Personnel and the survivors to other resources in their community. Their managers, their team leaders, the human resources. It might be an external supervisor, could be their mentors, family, friends, et cetera, so that they can start. The rebuilding process. It’s our job to help identify some possible positive experiences from the event.
And one of the examples that came up with the group that we did the debrief with post the fires was that because they’d spent so much time together as a team, they got to know each other at a whole different level. People who didn’t really know each other before that process really got to know each other. And formed some really strong friendships from that. That’s a positive that came out of a traumatic event. Other ones might be that you’ve actually lived through a traumatic event. You’re more robust because of the fact that you’ve got through it. We’re looking for those positive experiences, but we’re also anchoring them to supports that may need to be around.
Post that time. Often this is done in the form of saying this is our debrief process, but hey, we’ve got an open door or a telephone number. If at any stage. Something pops up. You just need to talk about it we’re here to help this some more anchoring there. We also need to think about the other resources that we have. Time off, holidays, getting back into the normality of our normal everyday work. These are things that help us to bring some closure. To the incident. The final point Step seven is that debriefing assists in the re-entry process back into the community or workplace. Now debriefing can be done in a large or small group, can be done in one to one as well depending on the situation.
Often we run it as a group in our critical incident debriefing with the organisation for the bushfires. We had about 20 people in the room. We need to remember that debriefing’s not a critique. We’re not there saying what went wrong and pulling that apart. That’s time for our review later. But it is a systematic review of the event leading to. During and after the crisis. And the after the crisis is our key point here. Our job in the debrief is to support people back into their community or workplace. All too often in our frameworks in the community services sector, we leave people out to dry when it comes to critical incidents.
I’ve got a number of friends and colleagues who have gone through. Critical incident, whether in the justice system, the youth justice system or in residential care or drug and alcohol, mental health. Where there’s been significant issues. I think one friend who was significantly injured in the youth justice space. And they were given some time off and their return to work plan was We’ll give you a few weeks and then we’ll start you back on two shifts. And then we’ll put you back into normality. That’s not re-entry. That’s not what the critical incident stress debriefing literature talks about when it comes to reentry. We need to provide the closure and the anchors and the.
Resources. So that people can feel safe and secure coming back into their. Place. If we haven’t done that, if we haven’t provided a workplace that is safe, that is a place where there are resources. And when we’re talking about resources, we’re not just talking about money and things, but the right people around them. Then The rest of our critical stress debrief. Is kind of useless. It doesn’t give closure, it doesn’t help them to come back into the. The fray. So that final point, and this is the bit that takes the longest in a critical incident stress debrief. Is assisting the reentry process. Now for some people.
They’ll just be able to get straight back to work. For others that’s going to take time and counselling and support. And easing it in, maybe changing duties, et cetera. But it is the key point. We need to help people to re-enter. So that’s the seven points to a critical incident stress debrief. And it’s a key part to the work that we do here at Ultimate. We do lots of supervision of individuals and groups, but all too often. We get called in to deal with critical incidents and to help. Of people to deal with the long-term effects that they will have. And the critical incident stress debrief is the framework that we use most often when it comes to that.
So that’s it, two. Very different frameworks, the after action report and the critical incident stress debrief. Like I said, if you don’t really have a critical incident stress debrief framework, start with the after action report. It’ll give you the space to begin a process of reflection and working out what works and what doesn’t work. But for those of you who want to take it up a notch or a bit more in a therapeutic space, We highly recommend the Critical Incident Stress Debriefing Framework those seven steps. If you don’t have a group or an organization that does this with you, we are more than happy to come along and run some sessions with your organization.
So that’s it for today. I hope that this has been something that’s been of interest to you. It’s one of those ones that’s a bit more in depth than we usually do, but it’s highly relevant and something that all organizations that work with people needs to have in their kit bag a good stress debriefing because we’re going to come across incidents. Every day. Thanks so much for listening and can you take the time once again to hit the subscribe button in your pod catcher of choice whether that’s iTunes, Stitcher, wherever you find us, just click that subscribe button. You’ll get every cast that we do come straight into your inbox.
That’s it from me. Take care. Stay frosty. For more information about Ultimate Youth Worker, please visit www.ultimateyouthworker.com.au
After a difficult event, our critical incident support can help your team. For ongoing support, see our supervision service.
Aaron Garth is a Melbourne-based youth worker, social worker and mental health practitioner with over two decades of experience supporting young people across Australia. As CEO of Ultimate Youth Worker, he leads a team that trains, coaches and supports professionals in the youth sector. A graduate of RMIT University and current PhD candidate, Aaron has worked in some of the toughest areas of youth services, from homelessness and mental health to drug and alcohol outreach and residential care. He speaks, teaches and advocates for a more professionalised youth workforce, and has taught at RMIT, Chisholm Institute and Eastern College Australia. His work rests on a simple belief: when youth workers are better supported, young people get better outcomes.